Can I offset EIS investment losses against my income tax?

Full answer

One of the most valuable but under-used features of the Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) is loss relief, which lets investors offset losses on failed or underperforming EIS shares against their income tax bill, not just against capital gains as with ordinary shares. **How EIS loss relief works** If you dispose of EIS shares at a loss (including if the company becomes worthless), you can choose to set that loss against your income for the current or previous tax year, rather than only being able to carry it against capital gains (which many investors may not have enough of to use fully). This choice, at your option, makes EIS considerably more attractive for high-risk early-stage investing than ordinary unlisted shares. **Calculating the 'net' loss for relief** The loss you can relieve is not simply the amount you invested minus what you got back -- it is calculated AFTER deducting any EIS income tax relief you already claimed on the original investment (normally 30% of the amount subscribed). This is because you have already had some of your investment 'refunded' via the initial tax relief, so only the true net-of-relief loss is available to relieve again. **Worked example** An investor subscribes £50,000 into EIS shares and claims the standard 30% income tax relief, reducing their tax bill by £15,000 in that year -- their true net cost is therefore £35,000 (£50,000 minus the £15,000 relief already received). The company later fails entirely and the shares become worthless. The allowable loss for EIS loss relief purposes is the net cost of £35,000, not the full £50,000 subscribed. If the investor is an additional rate (45%) taxpayer, claiming income tax loss relief on this £35,000 loss saves a further £15,750 (45% x £35,000) off their income tax bill. Combined with the original 30% income tax relief, the investor's overall effective loss is heavily cushioned by tax relief, even though the investment itself was a total washout commercially. **Choosing income tax relief vs CGT relief for the loss** An investor can elect to set the loss against income tax (at their marginal rate, which could be up to 45%) rather than against capital gains (at up to 24%), making the income tax route generally more valuable for higher and additional rate taxpayers, provided they have enough income tax liability in the relevant year to absorb the loss. **Why this matters for risk assessment** Because EIS-qualifying companies are inherently high-risk early-stage businesses with a meaningful chance of failure, the combination of upfront income tax relief plus loss relief on failure significantly changes the risk-adjusted economics of EIS investing compared with an equivalent non-EIS unlisted investment -- but investors should still never invest solely for the tax reliefs, since the underlying commercial risk of total capital loss remains real and the tax reliefs only cushion, rather than eliminate, that downside.

Try the calculator

More answers

• How does EIS deferral relief on Capital Gains Tax work?