What is chancel repair liability and does it still affect homebuyers?

Full answer

Chancel repair liability is one of the more obscure historic quirks of English property law, rooted in medieval arrangements between certain parishes and the owners of land that once belonged to or supported the church, and it occasionally still surfaces during conveyancing. **Where the liability comes from** Historically, some land (often former monastic or glebe land) carried an obligation for its owner to contribute towards the cost of repairing the chancel (the area around the altar) of the local Church of England parish church. This obligation could, in principle, pass with the land through generations of ownership, entirely independent of whether the current owner has any connection to or knowledge of the church. **The 2013 registration deadline** Following a landmark legal case (Aston Cantlow) confirming the liability could still be enforced, the government required chancel repair liabilities to be registered as a formal "local land charge" or noted against the property's title at the Land Registry by 13 October 2013. After this date, an UNREGISTERED chancel repair liability generally cannot be enforced against a new owner who buys the property, even if the liability technically still exists in law -- it becomes effectively unenforceable against anyone who wasn't already bound by it before the deadline. **What this means for buyers today** For the vast majority of residential purchases, chancel repair liability is now a non-issue in practice, because so few properties had the liability formally registered before the 2013 deadline. However, conveyancing solicitors still commonly carry out a chancel repair search (or check historic Land Registry records) as a routine precaution, particularly for older properties or those in parishes known to have historic chancel repair arrangements. **Indemnity insurance as standard practice** Even where the search comes back clear or the risk appears low, many conveyancers routinely recommend (or lenders require) a one-off, inexpensive chancel repair indemnity insurance policy, which protects the buyer financially in the rare event a claim is later made, without needing to prove definitively that no liability exists. **How much could be claimed** Where liability is enforceable, the amount is not fixed -- it can, in principle, be a share of the FULL cost of chancel repairs, which for a parish with a large or historic church requiring significant structural work could run into tens of thousands of pounds, split among all liable landowners in the parish, making the (admittedly rare) risk one worth insuring against cheaply rather than ignoring. **Practical tip** Don't be alarmed if your solicitor mentions chancel repair liability during conveyancing -- it is a standard, low-cost, routine check for many property purchases, and taking out the modest one-off indemnity policy (typically well under £100) if recommended is usually the simplest way to close off the risk entirely.

Try the calculator

More answers

• What is title indemnity insurance and when do I need it when buying a property?
• Can title defects on a leasehold property stop me getting a mortgage?