Are ETFs or investment trusts more tax efficient in the UK?

Full answer

For a UK investor the tax treatment of ETFs and investment trusts is broadly the same in principle, but two structural differences matter. Both pay dividends or income distributions that fall under the dividend allowance of GBP 500 for 2026/27, with anything above taxed at 10.75 percent (basic), 35.75 percent (higher) or 39.35 percent (additional) - rates that rose two points this year. Capital gains on selling either use the annual exempt amount of GBP 3,000, then 18 percent within your basic-rate band or 24 percent above it. The first key difference is reporting fund status. Most UK-domiciled investment trusts are UK companies, so gains are always capital. Many ETFs are domiciled offshore (commonly Ireland or Luxembourg). If an offshore ETF does not hold HMRC reporting fund status, your gain is taxed as an offshore income gain at income tax rates (up to 45 percent) instead of CGT rates, and you lose the CGT allowance. UK investors should therefore stick to ETFs with reporting fund status; most mainstream ones have it. The second difference is structure. Investment trusts are closed-ended companies that can trade at a premium or discount to net asset value and can gear (borrow), which adds risk and return variability but no special tax effect. ETFs trade close to NAV. Worked example: a higher-rate investor holds either vehicle outside an ISA and receives GBP 1,500 of dividends. The first GBP 500 is covered by the allowance; the remaining GBP 1,000 is taxed at 35.75 percent, so GBP 357.50 of tax - identical for both vehicles. The simplest fix for either is to hold inside an ISA (GBP 20,000 allowance) or pension, where dividends and gains are tax-free. Use the dividend tax and capital gains tax calculators to model the unwrapped position.

Try the calculator