What is shareholder protection insurance?

Full answer

Shareholder protection insurance addresses a specific risk facing privately owned companies with more than one shareholder: what happens to a business if one of the owners dies or becomes critically ill. **The problem it solves** Without planning, if a shareholder dies, their shares typically pass to their estate and then to their family or other beneficiaries under their will -- these new shareholders may have no interest in, or knowledge of, running the business, which can create serious disruption, disagreement, or even force a sale of the company against the wishes of the surviving owners. **How the insurance works** Each shareholder takes out a life insurance policy (often also including critical illness cover) written for an amount roughly equal to the value of their shareholding. If a shareholder dies (or suffers a covered critical illness, depending on the policy), the payout goes to the surviving shareholders (or the company itself, depending on the structure), giving them the funds needed to buy the deceased shareholder's shares from their estate at a fair, pre-agreed valuation. **The role of a cross-option agreement** Shareholder protection is typically combined with a legal document called a cross-option agreement (sometimes called a double option agreement), which gives the surviving shareholders the option to buy the shares, and gives the deceased's estate the option to sell them, at an agreed valuation -- this avoids either side being forced into a transaction, while still creating a clear, agreed mechanism for the shares to change hands smoothly. **Valuing the business** Getting the level of cover right requires a realistic valuation of each shareholder's stake, which should be reviewed periodically as the business grows -- underinsuring means the surviving shareholders may not have enough funds to complete the buyout even with a policy in place. **Who needs it** Any private limited company with two or more shareholders, particularly where the shareholders are also actively involved in running the business, should consider shareholder protection insurance as part of wider business succession planning, alongside a properly drafted cross-option or shareholders' agreement. **Worked example** Two business partners each own 50% of a company worth £1 million. Each takes out a life insurance policy for £500,000 (their share of the business value), written in trust. If one partner dies, the payout allows the surviving partner to buy the shares from the deceased partner's family at the agreed valuation, keeping full control of the business while the family receives fair value for the shares. **Practical tip** Review the sum insured and the underlying share valuation regularly as the business grows, and take specialist advice on structuring the policies and the cross-option agreement correctly, since getting the legal and tax structure wrong can undermine the protection you intended to put in place.

Try the calculator

More answers

• What is directors and officers (D&O) insurance?