Student Loan Plan 2 vs Plan 5: How Repayments Actually Differ in 2026/27
Plan 2 and Plan 5 student loans both charge 9% above a repayment threshold, but the thresholds and write-off terms are very different — and it makes a real difference to lifetime repayment for many graduates. Here's the side-by-side comparison.
The Core Numbers, Side by Side
| Feature | Plan 2 | Plan 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Who's on it | Most English/Welsh undergrads, started 2012-2023 | English undergrads, started Sept 2023 onwards |
| 2026/27 repayment threshold | £29,385/year | £25,000/year |
| Repayment rate above threshold | 9% | 9% |
| Interest rate basis | RPI, up to RPI+3% while studying/for higher earners | Capped at RPI |
| Write-off period | 30 years from first repayment due | 40 years from first repayment due |
The headline repayment rate is identical — 9% — so the difference comes entirely from the threshold, the interest structure, and how long the loan remains active before any unpaid balance is written off.
Worked Example: Same Salary, Different Plan
Take a graduate earning £32,000 a year, paid monthly.
| Plan | Annual threshold | Income above threshold | Annual repayment (9%) | Monthly repayment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan 2 | £29,385 | £2,615 | £235 | ~£19.60 |
| Plan 5 | £25,000 | £7,000 | £630 | ~£52.50 |
At this salary, the Plan 5 graduate repays roughly 2.7 times more per month than a Plan 2 graduate on the identical income, purely because of the lower threshold capturing a larger slice of their salary.
Why the Lower Threshold Doesn't Automatically Mean "Worse"
It's tempting to see Plan 5's lower threshold and higher monthly repayment as simply a worse deal, but the full picture is more nuanced:
- Longer write-off (40 vs 30 years) means Plan 5 graduates who don't clear their balance keep repaying for a decade longer than Plan 2 graduates would — more total months of 9% deductions.
- Interest capped at RPI for Plan 5, versus Plan 2's structure that can add up to 3 percentage points above RPI for higher earners, means Plan 5 balances may grow more slowly in real terms for higher earners specifically, even though more income is captured monthly.
- Total repaid depends entirely on lifetime earnings trajectory. A Plan 5 graduate who reaches high earnings quickly could, in principle, clear their loan before the 40-year mark — in which case the lower threshold accelerated repayment rather than extending total cost. A graduate on modest, steady earnings under Plan 5 is more likely to repay for the full 40 years, potentially repaying substantially more in absolute terms than an equivalent Plan 2 graduate would have over 30 years.
There is no single "better" answer that applies to all graduates — it depends heavily on projected career earnings.
What If You Have Loans on Two Plans?
Graduates with, for example, an undergraduate loan (Plan 2) and a postgraduate loan (Postgraduate Loan plan, threshold £21,000, rate 6%) repay both simultaneously via separate deductions, each calculated against its own threshold. This can mean a combined repayment rate above 9% of income above the lower threshold — worth factoring into take-home pay planning if considering further study.
| Loan type | 2026/27 threshold | Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Plan 1 | £26,900 | 9% |
| Plan 2 | £29,385 | 9% |
| Plan 4 (Scotland) | £33,795 | 9% |
| Plan 5 | £25,000 | 9% |
| Postgraduate Loan | £21,000 | 6% |
How to Check Which Plan You're On
Your plan type is fixed by your course start date and home nation at the time you took out the loan — not a choice you make. To confirm:
- Log into your Student Loans Company online account — the plan type is shown on your statement.
- Check your payslip if employed — most payslips show which plan your employer is deducting under (though errors do happen, particularly for graduates who've recently changed jobs).
- If you believe your employer is deducting under the wrong plan, contact HR/payroll directly — an incorrect plan type can mean over- or under-deduction, both of which need correcting with the Student Loans Company.
Because the difference between plans meaningfully changes monthly take-home pay, it's worth confirming your correct plan type is reflected on your payslip shortly after starting any new job, particularly for graduates who studied under Plan 5 and may be defaulted incorrectly to Plan 2 by an employer unfamiliar with the newer plan type.
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
Agency Nurse Tax and IR35 UK 2026: PAYE, Umbrella, or Limited Company?
Most agency nursing work is taxed via PAYE or an umbrella company, and NHS-facing agency roles are almost always treated as inside IR35, meaning limited company working rarely delivers the tax savings some nurses expect. Here is the 2026 breakdown.
Armed Forces Reservist Pay and Tax UK 2026/27
Reservist training pay and mobilisation pay are both taxable, but a reservist's civilian employer receives compensation for their absence, and specific NI rules apply during mobilisation. Here is how reservist pay and tax work in 2026/27.
Ex-Gratia Payments: Tax Treatment Explained 2026/27
A genuine ex-gratia payment on leaving a job can be received tax-free up to £30,000, on top of statutory redundancy pay, but only if it is truly not contractual or connected to services rendered. Here is the 2026/27 tax treatment.