UK Public Sector Pensions Compared 2026: NHS vs Teachers vs LGPS vs Civil Service
NHS, Teachers, LGPS and Civil Service Alpha pensions are among the best in the UK. Compare accrual rates, contributions, NPA and the annual allowance trap for 2026.
Why public sector pensions are exceptional
The United Kingdom has one of the last large groups of workers with defined benefit (DB) pensions: the public sector. Doctors, nurses, teachers, local government workers and civil servants still accrue pension based on their salary and years of service -- a benefit that is largely extinct in the private sector, where defined contribution (DC) schemes now dominate.
In a DC scheme, your pension depends on what the investment pot is worth when you retire. In a DB scheme, you receive a guaranteed income for life, inflation-proofed, with no investment risk to you. The employer (ultimately the taxpayer) bears the investment and longevity risk.
The four main public sector schemes are:
- NHS Pension Scheme (1995, 2008 and 2015 sections; all new entrants in 2015 section)
- Teachers Pension Scheme (TPS) (career average section for post-April 2015 members)
- Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) (England and Wales; separate schemes for Scotland and Northern Ireland)
- Civil Service Alpha (the post-April 2015 defined benefit scheme for civil servants)
Head-to-head comparison
| Feature | NHS 2015 | Teachers (CARE) | LGPS | Civil Service Alpha |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scheme type | CARE DB | CARE DB | CARE DB | CARE DB |
| Accrual rate | 1/54th | 1/57th | 1/49th | 1/43.1th |
| Normal Pension Age (NPA) | SPA (67) | SPA (67) | SPA (67) | SPA (67) |
| Employee contributions | 5.2% to 13.5% | 7.4% to 11.7% | 5.5% to 12.5% | 4.6% to 8.05% |
| Employer contributions | 23.7% | 28.68% | Varies (~20%) | 28.97% |
| In-deferment revaluation | CPI + 1.5% | CPI | CPI | CPI |
| Pension in payment | CPI | CPI | CPI | CPI |
| Death in service (lump sum) | 2x salary | 3x salary | 3x salary | 2x salary |
| Ill-health tier | 2-tier | 2-tier | 2-tier | 2-tier |
| 50/50 section available | No | No | Yes | No |
Reading the accrual rate
The accrual rate tells you how much pension you earn per year of service, as a fraction of that year's pensionable pay. For example:
- NHS 1/54th: Earn £54,000 in 2026/27 -- accrue £1,000 pension per year.
- LGPS 1/49th: Earn £54,000 -- accrue £1,102 pension per year.
- Alpha 1/43.1th: Earn £54,000 -- accrue £1,253 pension per year.
The Alpha accrual is 25% better than NHS for the same salary. Over a 30-year career on the same average salary, an Alpha member would have a pension approximately £7,500/year higher than an NHS member.
NHS Pension Scheme
The NHS Pension Scheme (NHSPS) is one of the largest defined benefit schemes in the world, covering over 2 million active members. From 1 April 2022, all members were moved into the 2015 Section (career average) as the McCloud remedy came into effect.
Contributions (2026/27):
| Pensionable pay band | Employee contribution |
|---|---|
| Up to £13,259 | 5.2% |
| £13,260 to £26,831 | 6.5% |
| £26,832 to £47,846 | 8.3% |
| £47,847 to £111,376 | 10.4% |
| Above £111,376 | 13.5% |
Employer contributions are 23.7% of pensionable pay, paid by NHS trusts, GP practices and other NHS employers.
The death-in-service lump sum is 2 times annual pensionable pay. A dependant's pension (typically 37.5% of member's pension) is also payable.
Ill-health retirement: Two tiers. Tier 1 (temporary incapacity): pension based on accrued benefits. Tier 2 (permanent incapacity): enhanced pension using projected service to NPA (capped at 10 years' extra service).
Teachers Pension Scheme
The Teachers Pension Scheme (TPS) covers teachers in maintained schools, academies, further education colleges and some independent schools in England and Wales. It has approximately 700,000 active members.
The accrual rate of 1/57th is the lowest of the four schemes, but employer contributions at 28.68% are among the highest, which contributes to the scheme's overall generosity.
Contributions (2026/27):
| Pensionable pay band | Employee contribution |
|---|---|
| Up to £32,135 | 7.4% |
| £32,136 to £43,259 | 8.6% |
| £43,260 to £51,292 | 9.7% |
| £51,293 to £67,493 | 10.7% |
| Above £67,493 | 11.7% |
The TPS provides 3 times annual pensionable pay as a death-in-service lump sum -- more generous than NHS or Alpha.
Headteachers and senior leaders are most at risk of the Annual Allowance trap, as significant pay progression in the final years of a career can create large pension input amounts.
Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS)
The LGPS is unique among the four main public sector schemes in being a funded scheme -- contributions are invested in local authority pension funds (there are 86 administering authorities in England and Wales). The other three schemes are unfunded pay-as-you-go arrangements backed by the Treasury.
The funded nature means LGPS member benefits are backed by real assets but also introduces some financial risk to the funds (though benefits remain contractually guaranteed by the employer).
Distinctive features:
- 50/50 section: Members can elect to pay half the normal contribution rate and accrue half the normal pension. Useful for those facing temporary financial difficulty.
- Employer contribution varies: Determined by triennial actuarial valuation of each individual fund. Average is approximately 20%, but ranges from under 15% to over 30% depending on the fund's funding level.
- Discretionary increases: Administering authorities can award discretionary increases in exceptional circumstances.
The LGPS 1/49th accrual makes it the second most generous in terms of benefit build-up.
Civil Service Alpha
Alpha is the defined benefit pension scheme for most civil servants, introduced from 1 April 2015 alongside the career average reforms.
With an accrual rate of 1/43.1th, Alpha provides the most generous annual build-up of the four schemes. A senior civil servant on £85,000 accrues approximately £1,972 of pension per year -- a very substantial benefit.
Employee contribution tiers (2026/27):
| Pensionable earnings | Employee contribution |
|---|---|
| Up to £23,100 | 4.6% |
| £23,101 to £45,500 | 5.45% |
| £45,501 to £77,000 | 7.35% |
| Above £77,000 | 8.05% |
Employer contributions are approximately 28.97% -- among the highest of any employer in the UK.
Civil servants who joined before 2015 may have accrued benefits in the Classic, Classic Plus, Premium or Nuvos legacy schemes, and the McCloud remedy entitles them to compare benefits for the 2015-2022 period.
The Annual Allowance trap
All four schemes measure pension growth against the Annual Allowance (AA) using a factor of 16x the increase in pension entitlement.
For 2026/27 the AA is £60,000. A pension increase of £3,750/year would use the full allowance (£3,750 x 16 = £60,000).
The trap is most acute for:
- NHS consultants: who may see large pension increases due to Clinical Excellence Awards, pay progression or one-off distinction awards.
- Headteachers and senior teachers: whose salary and pension increase sharply with promotion.
- Senior civil servants: particularly in the Senior Civil Service pay band, where pension grows rapidly.
Where the AA is breached, the individual faces an AA charge at their marginal income tax rate on the excess. Pension Scheme Pays allows the scheme to pay the charge, reducing the eventual pension at retirement.
The AA taper further reduces the allowance for high earners: for those with adjusted income above £260,000, the allowance reduces by £1 for every £2 over the threshold, to a minimum of £10,000.
McCloud remedy
The 2018 McCloud judgment found that transitional protections offered to older members when the 2015 CARE schemes were introduced (allowing them to remain in their legacy final salary schemes) were age-discriminatory.
The remedy, implemented from 1 October 2023, gives all eligible members a retrospective "choice" (known as the deferred choice underpin or DCU) for the period 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2022: at the point of taking benefits, they choose between:
- Legacy (final salary) benefits for that period; or
- New CARE benefits for that period.
HMRC and schemes will work out both options at the point of retirement. Members should be aware that the better option depends on their final salary at retirement relative to the CARE benefits accrued.
Comparing with private sector
For context, the average employer pension contribution in the private sector is approximately 4.5% (above the 3% auto-enrolment minimum, but well below public sector rates). Most private sector workers are in DC schemes with no guaranteed benefit.
A private sector employee and a public sector employee both earning £50,000 might compare pension outcomes as follows:
| Feature | Private DC (average) | NHS CARE |
|---|---|---|
| Employer contribution | ~4.5% (£2,250/year) | 23.7% (£11,850/year) |
| Benefit at retirement | Depends on investments | Guaranteed income for life |
| Inflation protection | None guaranteed | CPI-linked |
| Investment risk | Employee bears | Employer/taxpayer bears |
The public sector employer contribution advantage alone is worth tens of thousands of pounds over a career.
Pension Calculator
Estimate your pension pot at retirement and projected annual income.
Open Pension calculatorSources
- NHS Employers: NHS Pension Scheme member guidance
- Teachers Pension Scheme: Member hub
- LGPS Regulations 2013; LGPS Advisory Board: lgpsregs.org
- Cabinet Office: Civil Service pension scheme
- HMRC: Annual Allowance
- Supreme Court: McCloud/Sargeant judgment 2018
Frequently asked questions
Are public sector pensions defined benefit?
Yes. All four main public sector schemes -- NHS, Teachers Pension Scheme, LGPS and Civil Service Alpha -- are defined benefit (DB), specifically career average revalued earnings (CARE) schemes. Benefits are based on pensionable pay each year, revalued to retirement, not on investment returns. This is far more generous and predictable than the defined contribution (DC) schemes that most private sector workers now have.
What is the Normal Pension Age for public sector schemes?
For most members in post-2015 schemes, the Normal Pension Age (NPA) is linked to State Pension Age -- currently 67 for those born after 1960. Members can take pension earlier (from age 55, rising to 57 in 2028) but benefits are reduced by an actuarial factor for each year taken early.
What is the McCloud remedy?
The McCloud case found that age-related transitional protections when the new CARE schemes were introduced in 2015 were discriminatory. The remedy (effective 1 October 2023) gives affected members a choice at retirement between their legacy final salary benefits and the new CARE benefits for the period 1 April 2015 to 31 March 2022. Members should compare both options carefully.
Why do consultants and senior teachers get an annual allowance tax charge?
Public sector CARE pensions are measured for Annual Allowance (AA) purposes using a factor of 16x the benefit increase. Consultants and senior clinicians often accrue large pension benefits in a single year due to promotions or pay rises, breaching the £60,000 AA. The same applies to senior teachers, headteachers and senior civil servants. The AA charge is taxed at the individual's marginal rate.
What happens if I opt out of my public sector pension?
You lose employer contributions (up to 23-29% of salary -- one of the most valuable employer contributions in the country) and stop accruing DB benefits. You also lose death-in-service and ill-health cover. For most public sector workers, opting out is poor value unless extreme financial hardship requires the extra take-home pay. Benefits already accrued are preserved and revalued to your NPA.
Which public sector pension has the best accrual rate?
Civil Service Alpha has the best accrual rate at 1/43.1th per year. LGPS is second at 1/49th, NHS third at 1/54th, and Teachers Pension Scheme last at 1/57th. However, employer contributions, revaluation terms, and death benefits vary, so the comparison is not solely about accrual.
Do public sector pensions increase with inflation in retirement?
Yes -- all four schemes increase pensions in payment by the Consumer Prices Index (CPI). The NHS scheme revalues deferred benefits at CPI+1.5% while in deferment; the others use CPI only. This inflation linkage is a major advantage over DC pensions, which have no guarantee of future income growth.
Can I draw my public sector pension and continue working?
Yes. In most schemes you can take your pension and continue in the same job (subject to scheme rules). In the NHS scheme, drawing pension while returning to NHS employment (abatement rules) was abolished for the 2015 scheme. In Alpha, civil servants can return to work after taking pension without abatement. Local rules vary -- check your scheme's re-employment provisions.
Try the calculators
In-depth guides
Related reading
Civil Service Alpha Pension Scheme Explained 2026/27
How the alpha civil service pension scheme works in 2026/27 — accrual rate, contribution tiers, normal pension age and how it compares to a private-sector defined contribution pension.
NHS Pension Scheme 2026/27: Career Average Benefits, Contributions and Retirement
The NHS Pension Scheme 2015 gives career-average benefits with CPI+1.5% revaluation and employer contributions of 23.7%. This guide covers contribution tiers, the accrual rate, worked examples and the McCloud remedy.
Teachers Pension Scheme UK 2026: Career Average, Contributions and Benefits
The Teachers Pension Scheme 2015 provides career-average benefits with CPI revaluation and a 28.68% employer contribution. This guide covers contribution tiers, legacy final salary benefits, the McCloud remedy and worked examples.