Title Indemnity Insurance: When You Need It and What It Costs
Title indemnity insurance covers legal defects in a property's title — missing planning permission, restrictive covenant breaches, absent easements — that would otherwise delay or derail a sale. Here's how it works, typical costs, and when solicitors recommend it.
What Title Indemnity Insurance Is For
When solicitors carry out conveyancing searches and due diligence during a property purchase, they sometimes uncover a legal "defect" in the title — something that, technically, could allow a third party to take action against the current or future owner. Rather than delaying or cancelling the sale while the defect is formally resolved (which can take months or be impossible), the standard market solution is a one-off title indemnity insurance policy.
The insurance doesn't cure the underlying problem. Instead, it transfers the financial risk of that specific, already-identified defect to an insurer, who will pay out (up to the policy limit, usually the property's value) if the defect ever causes a loss.
Common Defects Covered by Indemnity Insurance
| Defect Type | Example | Typical Policy |
|---|---|---|
| Missing building regulations certificate | Extension built 15 years ago, no sign-off found | Building regulations indemnity policy |
| Missing planning permission | Loft conversion built without permission, now beyond the 4-year enforcement period | Lack of planning permission indemnity policy |
| Restrictive covenant breach | Covenant against building a second dwelling, breached decades ago | Restrictive covenant indemnity policy |
| Absent or unclear right of way | No formal easement for a shared driveway | Right of way / easement indemnity policy |
| Unregistered land | Property has never been registered at HM Land Registry | Possessory title / unregistered land indemnity |
| Chancel repair liability | See our separate chancel repair liability guide | Chancel repair indemnity policy |
| Flying freehold | Part of the building overhangs a neighbour's land without formal rights | Flying freehold indemnity policy |
Each type of defect typically has its own dedicated policy product, and a single transaction can require more than one if multiple issues are found.
How the Insurance Process Works
- Defect identified — usually during searches, survey, or the seller's disclosure (TA6 form).
- Solicitor assesses severity — is it a minor technical issue (most planning/building regs gaps) or something more serious that needs specific legal advice rather than insurance?
- Quote obtained — solicitors typically use specialist indemnity insurance panels or brokers; quotes can often be obtained same-day.
- Policy purchased — usually a single premium paid at completion, added to the completion statement.
- Policy held indefinitely — most policies run with the land and benefit successors in title (future buyers), which is a valuable selling point.
Important: the policy generally must be taken out before the defect is disclosed to anyone who could benefit from taking action (e.g. a neighbour who benefits from a restrictive covenant). Once someone has raised a specific objection or claim, standard indemnity insurance is usually no longer available for that issue, because the risk has "crystallised" — at that point it becomes a legal dispute, not an insurable unknown risk.
Typical Premium Costs
| Property Value | Missing Building Regs (typical) | Restrictive Covenant Breach (typical) | Lack of Planning Permission (typical) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Under £250,000 | £20–£40 | £30–£60 | £40–£80 |
| £250,000–£500,000 | £30–£60 | £50–£90 | £70–£130 |
| £500,000–£1,000,000 | £50–£100 | £90–£160 | £130–£250 |
| Over £1,000,000 | Individually quoted | Individually quoted | Individually quoted |
These are one-off premiums, not annual costs — a key difference from most other insurance products. The relatively low cost, compared to the alternative of a delayed or collapsed sale, is why they're used so routinely.
Who Pays: Buyer or Seller?
Market convention places the cost with the seller, because the defect typically arose during their period of ownership (or an earlier owner's). However:
- In a strong seller's market, the buyer may be asked to cover it or accept the property "as seen" without insurance.
- In a weaker market, sellers are more likely to fund it without objection to keep the sale moving.
- For newer defects (e.g. an extension the current seller built themselves), the seller almost always pays, since it was their own act that created the risk.
- It is a standard, low-stakes negotiating point in most transactions and rarely holds up a deal on its own.
Mortgage Lender Considerations
Lenders generally accept title indemnity insurance as resolving most common, low-severity defects, provided:
- The insurer is on the lender's approved panel (most major insurers are on all mainstream panels).
- The policy amount is sufficient to cover the current property value (some lenders require cover equal to the loan amount plus a margin, others require full market value).
- The defect is not something the lender's own solicitor flags as too fundamental for insurance alone — such as serious title fraud, a boundary dispute already in litigation, or land subject to ongoing enforcement action by a local authority.
For most routine defects — a decades-old missing certificate, an old and unenforced covenant — lenders proceed without further complication once the policy is in place.
When Insurance Isn't the Right Answer
Indemnity insurance is a practical tool, not a universal fix. It's generally not appropriate when:
- The defect is already the subject of an active dispute or enforcement notice.
- The beneficiary of a covenant or easement is aware of the breach and has objected.
- The buyer intends to carry out further building work that would make the existing defect (e.g. an unauthorised extension) worse or trigger fresh scrutiny.
- The defect affects the fundamental ability to use or mortgage the property (e.g. no legal access at all).
In these cases, proper legal resolution — retrospective planning permission, a deed of variation, or a formal easement — is usually necessary rather than relying on insurance to paper over the risk.
Frequently asked questions
Related reading
CGT Property Calculator: Selling a Second Home or Rental Property 2026/27
Selling a second home or buy-to-let in 2026/27 means Capital Gains Tax at 18% or 24% on the gain above your £3,000 annual exemption, reported and paid within 60 days of completion. Full worked examples.
Equity Release Interest Roll-Up: How Compounding Interest Eats Into Your Estate
Most lifetime mortgages (the most common form of equity release) charge interest that compounds and rolls up rather than being paid monthly. Here's how quickly that can grow — and what it means for Inheritance Tax and what's left for your beneficiaries.
Garden Rooms, Permitted Development and Tax 2026/27
A garden room or home office pod built under permitted development usually needs no planning permission, but the tax treatment differs sharply depending on whether you use it for a business, rent it out, or add it to a rental property. Here is how it works in 2026/27.