Comparison · Limited Company Tax · 2026
Director's Loan vs Dividend 2026: Which Extraction Method Costs Less?
Company directors sometimes take money out as an informal loan rather than a dividend -- sometimes deliberately, sometimes because a dividend was declared without enough distributable profit. The two are taxed completely differently. This guide compares them for 2026/27.
TL;DR -- 30-Second Summary
- • Dividend: permanent distribution, taxed on the director at 10.75%/35.75%/39.35% (2026/27), GBP 500 allowance
- • Director's loan: repayable, no personal tax if repaid within 9 months of the year end
- • S455 charge (35.75%) hits the company, not the director, on any loan unpaid after 9 months
- • Loans over GBP 10,000 that are interest-free create a separate benefit-in-kind tax charge
- • A dividend can only be paid from genuine distributable (post-tax) profits
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Director's loan | Dividend |
|---|---|---|
| Repayable? | Yes, expected to be repaid | No -- permanent distribution |
| Requires distributable profit? | No | Yes -- must be legal |
| Personal tax if repaid on time | None | Always -- 10.75%/35.75%/39.35% |
| Company-level charge if unpaid at 9 months | S455 at 35.75% | Not applicable |
| Benefit-in-kind risk | Yes, if over GBP 10,000 and interest-free | No |
| Tax-free dividend allowance | Not applicable | GBP 500 (2026/27) |
Worked Example: Taking GBP 10,000 Out of the Company
A higher-rate taxpayer director needs GBP 10,000 for a personal expense and compares two routes: a dividend declared from distributable profit, versus a director's loan.
| Scenario | Dividend route | Loan route |
|---|---|---|
| Amount taken | GBP 10,000 | GBP 10,000 |
| If repaid within 9 months of year end | Not applicable -- dividends are not repaid | GBP 0 tax (subject to benefit-in-kind rule above GBP 10,000) |
| Higher-rate dividend tax (35.75% above the GBP 500 allowance) | Roughly GBP 3,394 on the taxable portion | Not applicable |
| If loan left unpaid past 9 months | Not applicable | GBP 3,575 S455 charge on the company (35.75%), reclaimable later |
A director's loan genuinely repaid on time can be far cheaper than a dividend of the same size, because no tax arises on either side. The moment the loan is left unpaid past the 9-month deadline, though, the company faces a 35.75% S455 charge -- almost identical in rate to the higher-rate dividend tax the director would have paid anyway, except the S455 charge lands on the company's cash flow rather than the director's personal tax bill, and is only reclaimed much later.
When a Director's Loan Wins
A director's loan wins for genuine short-term timing gaps -- for example bridging a personal expense a few weeks before an expected dividend or bonus -- where the director is confident the balance will be cleared well within 9 months of the company's year end, and where the balance stays under (or close to) GBP 10,000 to avoid the benefit-in-kind rule.
When a Dividend Wins
A dividend wins whenever the money is genuinely being extracted for good, not borrowed -- it is simpler to administer, has no repayment deadline to track, and avoids any risk of an S455 charge or a benefit-in-kind P11D entry. For regular income extraction from an owner-managed company, dividends from distributable profit remain the standard, lower-risk route.
Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the fundamental difference between a director's loan and a dividend?
A dividend is a permanent distribution of company profit to a shareholder -- it is not repaid and is taxed on the individual through dividend tax. A director's loan is money the company lends the director personally, which is expected to be repaid, and if it is not repaid within 9 months of the company's year end, the company itself (not the director) faces a separate corporate tax charge under section 455 (S455) of the Corporation Tax Act 2010.
How much is the S455 tax charge in 2026/27?
The S455 charge is set at the dividend upper rate, which for 2026/27 is 35.75%. It applies to the company on any part of an outstanding director's loan that is not repaid, released or written off within 9 months of the end of the accounting period in which it was made. Unlike dividend tax, S455 is a company-level charge, not a personal tax on the director, though it is refundable to the company once the loan is eventually repaid.
Can the S455 charge be reclaimed?
Yes. Once the director's loan is repaid, HMRC will refund the S455 charge to the company, but not immediately -- the refund is only claimed 9 months after the end of the accounting period in which the loan was repaid, which can mean waiting well over a year for the cash to come back. This delay is one of the main reasons an unpaid director's loan can be an expensive way to fund short-term personal spending compared with simply taking a dividend.
Show 7 more questionsShow fewer questions
What are the dividend tax rates for 2026/27?
Dividend income has its own GBP 500 tax-free dividend allowance for 2026/27, then is taxed at 10.75% within the basic rate band, 35.75% within the higher rate band, and 39.35% within the additional rate band -- all charged on the individual director as a shareholder, on top of whatever Corporation Tax the company already paid on its profits before the dividend was declared.
Is a director's loan taxed if repaid on time?
If a director's loan is repaid in full within 9 months of the company's year end, no S455 charge arises at all. However, if the loan exceeds GBP 10,000 at any point during the tax year and is interest-free or charged below HMRC's official rate, it is treated as a benefit in kind, reportable on a P11D, and both the director (income tax on the benefit) and the company (Class 1A employer NI on the benefit) face a separate tax cost even though the S455 charge itself was avoided.
Does the company need enough retained profit to pay a dividend?
Yes. A dividend can legally only be paid out of the company's distributable (post-tax) profits, confirmed by up-to-date management accounts at the time of declaration. Paying a dividend when the company does not have sufficient distributable reserves creates an illegal dividend, which HMRC can recharacterise as a loan or as earnings, with different and often worse tax consequences than either a properly declared dividend or a properly documented loan.
Which is cheaper for a short-term cash need: a loan or a dividend?
For a genuinely short-term need that will be repaid well within 9 months of the company's year end, a director's loan can be effectively tax-free (subject to the benefit-in-kind rule on loans over GBP 10,000), because no S455 charge or dividend tax arises at all. A dividend is always taxed on the director once declared, regardless of how quickly the money is later returned to the company informally, since a dividend cannot simply be 'repaid' the way a loan can.
What happens if a director's loan is written off instead of repaid?
If the company formally writes off a director's loan rather than the director repaying it, the written-off amount is treated as a dividend (if the director is also a shareholder, which is normal for small companies) or as earnings subject to PAYE and NI, and the S455 charge the company previously paid becomes reclaimable. Writing off a loan can create both a personal income tax charge for the director and an NI cost, so it is rarely a cheap way to clear an overdrawn loan account.
Can a company pay both a dividend and maintain a director's loan account?
Yes, and many small companies use a mix: a modest salary up to the NI threshold, dividends up to the basic-rate band from distributable profits, and short-term director's loans for genuine timing gaps between company cash flow and personal spending. The two are independent -- a company can have an outstanding, compliant director's loan and still separately declare dividends, as long as distributable profits actually support the dividend.
Do I need an accountant to manage a director's loan account?
It is strongly advisable. The 9-month repayment deadline, the GBP 10,000 benefit-in-kind threshold, the S455 reclaim timing, and the interaction with dividend legality rules are easy to get wrong without proper bookkeeping, and HMRC actively checks director's loan accounts on company tax returns. Most small company accountants track the loan account balance throughout the year specifically to flag repayment deadlines before they are missed.
Related calculators
Corporation Tax tool
Calculate Corporation Tax for UK limited companies for 2025/26.
Calculate your Dividend Tax
Calculate tax on dividends received from UK companies for 2025/26.
Dividend vs Salary Calculator
Compare taking income as salary vs dividends as a limited company director. See which method saves more tax in 2026/27.
Check your Salary in Foreign Currency
See your UK take-home pay converted into Polish zloty, Ukrainian hryvnia, Romanian leu or euro at live rates.
Disclaimer: This comparison is general information for 2026/27 based on standard S455 and dividend tax rules and simplified assumptions. It is not tax advice. Director's loan account rules are fact-specific and closely checked by HMRC -- take advice from a qualified accountant before relying on either route.